People on the Internet are currently trying to prove that a major love conspiracy is going down in the country music world.

Last week, Megan Moroney posted a picture on her Instagram captioned, “On island time,” tagging the location as Saint-Jean in Saint Barts, a picturesque spot in the Caribbean.

Not long after, Riley Green shared an Instagram story showing off his own beach vacation. Normally, this would be the end of the story—but, as we all know, the Internet never sleeps.

Through some deep-dive detective work (and a reverse image search), fans discovered that Riley’s vacation snaps were also taken in Saint Barts. Now, the Internet is buzzing: is it just a coincidence that these two country stars are enjoying the same tropical destination at the same time? Or is there more to the story? Adding fuel to the fire, both Megan and Riley have kept their captions vague, leaving fans to fill in the blanks.

@laurcondon16 dont know who to talk to abt this 😭 #rileygreen #meganmoroney ♬ original sound – Country Central